close
close

Yiamastaverna

Trusted News & Timely Insights

The most heartbreaking scene in an M. Night Shyamalan film is also the most rewarding
Albany

The most heartbreaking scene in an M. Night Shyamalan film is also the most rewarding

The big picture

  • Unbreakable
    is one of Shyamalan’s best films, presenting gripping human drama and eye-catching spectacle.
  • The heart of
    Unbreakable
    lies in the emotional father-son dynamic between David and Joseph.
  • Shyamalan’s camera work in
    Unbreakable
    shows his unique narrative style and his eye for composition.



Few filmmakers have had such a successful career as M. Night Shyamalanwhose early thriller hits made him a star before a series of critical failures damaged his reputation. Although his name is associated with some films that many considered disastrous, Shyamalan’s ambition and seriousness led to a second wave of B-movie thrillers such as Splits, Oldand his latest Trapwith Josh HartnettThese films have caused division among fans and critics. Some of them welcome his modern, original and imaginative films, while others consider his early works to be his most successful, especially The sixth Sense.


Although The sixth Sense may be the film with the greatest cultural impact in Shyamalan’s oeuvre, but his most powerful cinematography comes in his next film. UnbreakableShyamalan’s fourth film, had a rather quiet reputation when it was released in 2000. The sixth Sense would be a difficult task for any filmmaker, but in the nearly 25 years since Unbreakableis that it is one of Shyamalan’s best films. Bruce Willis Stars in Unbreakable as David Dunn, a man who survives a catastrophic train accident completely unharmed and discovers that he may have superhuman abilities. Willis is accompanied by Samuel L. Jackson as Mr. Glass, the comic-obsessed antagonist with a bone disease, Robin Wright as Dunn’s wife Audrey and Spencer Treat Clark as Joseph, the little son of Audrey and David.


The heart of the film is the dynamic between David and Josephas Joseph, trying to build a relationship with his father, doubts his father’s abilities. Their relationship culminates in an emotional climax that is the most powerful moment in all of Shyamalan’s work. The film is a loving, passionate homage to comic book archetypes. The superhero genre has experienced a boom in the following years and is so saturated that many no longer like anything with this label. What makes Unbreakable The difference is that it avoids flashy spectacles and instead focuses on a captivating human drama that is emphasized and thematically structured by media superhero clichés. Unbreakable offers a well-founded and incredibly convincing approach.



“Unbreakable” is one of M. Night Shyamalan’s best films

M. Night Shyamalan quickly developed a reputation as the “next Steven Spielberg” after his first hits, after a 2002 Newsweek cover story branded him as such. Arguably, that announcement allowed Shyamalan to deliver a standard of quality that simply no filmmaker could match, but his career has also weathered difficult times, and he has come out the other side proving himself to be one of our most visionary, unique genre filmmakers. Along with his penchant for telling gripping stories with interwoven, twisting narrative threads, his eye for composition is one of Shyamalan’s greatest strengths as a filmmaker.

Related

M. Night Shyamalan’s best sci-fi thriller is one of Max’s most-watched films this week

In “Signs,” Mel Gibson plays a former priest who is forever changed by the discovery of crop circles in his fields.


Shyamalan and Spielberg certainly have one thing in common: Both understand and skillfully use motivated camera movements even in the most rudimentary scenes. In Unbreakablewe are introduced to David Dunn on a train, and what follows is a back and forth between him and a woman he is courting for a possible affair. What easily could have been filmed in a wide shot or using the simple shot-reverse shot method is instead framed as a cinematic tennis match, with the camera positioned in front of Dunn and the woman panning back and forth, offering only a narrow view between the rows of seats on the train. This dynamic direction is a great example of the extra effort seen on screen in Shyamalan’s films. Another of these great camera moves occurs when Dunn begins adding weights to his bench press and the camera moves back and forth with his reps to symbolize his newfound, superhuman strength. This scene in Dunn’s home gym is also crucial to the father-son dynamic at the center of the film’s most striking moment.


M. Night Shyamalan’s humanistic approach makes the climax of “Unbreakable” so captivating

After David saves some children from a burglar, a story about it appears in the local newspaper and Joseph reads it at the breakfast table. Joseph becomes emotional when he realizes that he was right all along and that his father Is a real superhero is enough to bring tears to your eyes. Clark’s performance as a child processing this overwhelming information and looking up at his father with his mouth almost open is remarkable. Willis gives a perfect, knowing response by simply miming a “shhh” gesture to convey that it must remain a secret between David and Joseph. There is a scene in The White shark Where Roy Scheider and his on-screen son share an endearing moment at the dinner table as his son mimics Scheider’s exhausted, stressed body language. It speaks to the simple resonance of a compelling father-son relationship on screen, and the loving admiration a son can feel for his father. Unbreakable takes the basic situation of a father-son moment while eating together and turns it into a powerful, exciting moment.


This scene is also a real blast as it shows the tension between David and Joseph that has been building up throughout the film. Joseph became suspicious of his father’s abilities fairly early on in the story and became frustrated with David’s refusal to acknowledge them. This culminates in a tense scene where Joseph pulls a gun on David in their family kitchen and David and Audrey have to talk him out of using it as it could put them all in danger.

Unbreakablea relatively low-budget film that plays lovingly with superhero cliches, it doesn’t offer the fast-paced, explosive action of modern superhero films. Instead, Shyamalan puts all the emphasis on character moments like that breakfast scene. Unbreakable is both a human drama and a superhuman thrillerand every moment Joseph and David share in this film speaks to Shyamalan’s true strength. His narratives are shocking, his films are sophisticated, but the greatest strength of Shyamalan’s skill is the fact that he always wears his heart on his sleeve. The catharsis, recognition and awe that Joseph’s face shows as he looks up at his father says more about heroism than any dramatic defeat ever could, and that sincerity is why Shyamalan’s stories will always matter in an industry that’s becoming increasingly cynical.


Unbreakable is available in the US on Max

Watch on Max

LEAVE A RESPONSE

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *