close
close

Yiamastaverna

Trusted News & Timely Insights

Kansas City family expected to pay  million in wrongful death lawsuit related to 911 call
Michigan

Kansas City family expected to pay $4 million in wrongful death lawsuit related to 911 call

KANSAS CITY, Missouri (KCTV) — Kansas City and the Kansas City Police Department will pay a Prairie Village, Kansas, man $4.124 million to settle a wrongful death lawsuit against his wife five years ago. The settlement is expected to be formally approved by the Finance Committee on Thursday.

The lawsuit alleges that delays and errors by callers during a 911 call led to the death of 41-year-old Cathryn McClelland. The settlement also leads to changes within the 911 system.

Cathryn was 41 years old when she collapsed one morning in her home in Prairie Village. Her husband was at a construction site in Iowa. She was home alone with her two young children. She died four days after the 911 call.

“It’s been a long, four-year fight to get justice for this family,” said Brian McCallister, the family’s attorney. “(Cathryn) died because call takers didn’t do what they should have been trained to do. The 911 system in Kansas City failed Cathryn and her family.”

Confusion from the start

When Cathryn collapsed, her son Joel called 911. But the call went to Kansas City. There was confusion about the address. The callers did not trust the child to know his address.

KCTV5 received the recording as an aid when it first reported on the case several years ago.

It started with 8-year-old Joel explaining the situation.

JOEL: So, I’m just a kid with my little sister and my mom is on the floor and my dad is out of town.

KCPD: Do you know your address?

JOEL: Let me go out. Prairie Village, Belinder Avenue.

The boy gives an address, but quickly realizes his mistake and gives the correct address. This is one minute and ten seconds into the conversation.

ALSO READ: Seniors investigate the mysterious death of a Kansas City woman. It turns out she is alive.

Apparently the caller is still not sure. The mapping software shows that the call is coming from another location, within walking distance of where the child is supposedly located. It is decided to call an adult – Frank McClennen, who works in Iowa.

KCPD: This is the Kansas City Missouri Police Department…who am I speaking with?

FRANK: Frank McClelland.

Frank gives the address again. It is the same one the child gave them.

KCPD: You say this is Prairie Village, Kansas?

FRANK: Yes. What’s going on?

KCPD: I don’t know. He said his mother fell on the floor. She’s laying there and she’s not awake. We have him on the line, we just needed to confirm the address.

Frank: Oh, Jesus!

This is the case after five and a half minutes of the conversation.

KCPD and KCFD discuss where to route the call. After nine and a half minutes, Prairie Village police were called. But it took nearly 13 minutes for an ambulance to be dispatched to the house.

‘He is my hero’

“When I heard the call, I couldn’t believe what I was hearing,” Frank McClelland told us in a previous interview. “My son had called and in a very short time provided information to help his mother.”

“He did everything he could to convince them,” said Frank. “He was calm. He could express himself well. I’ve told him ever since: He’s my hero.”

Medical records show that the young mother suffered a cardiac arrest. Cathryn’s heart rhythm was restored, but her brain suffered from a lack of oxygen. She was taken off life support and became an organ donor.

Cathryn’s Code

Part of the settlement requires the city to implement a new policy called “Cathryn’s Code,” which requires at least 50 recorded emergency calls each month to be randomly selected and analyzed for quality assurance.

ALSO READ: What is justice? Kansas City man sentenced to prison after years of clean living

“Frank McClelland felt this was an essential part of his settlement with the Kansas City, Missouri, Police Department to make the Kansas City community a safer place to live,” McCallister said. “With this necessary part of the settlement, the McClelland family will know that something good can come from Cathryn’s death to compensate for the McClelland family’s loss.”

KCTV5 Investigates contacted other local departments to see if they have quality control programs in place. Those local departments did not respond, but St. Louis Police did. They have an established quality control program and reviewed an average of more than 40 calls per month last year.

Personnel problems at 911

Staffing the 911 emergency number is a perennial problem in Kansas City. A shortage of callers and dispatchers means longer wait times for people needing help in an emergency.

In July, people in Kansas City waited an average of 52 seconds.

Mayor Quinton Lucas called the wait times urgent. He suggested combining police and fire call centers or possibly automating calls where people can select what they need – fire, police or ambulance.

The family’s attorney says Kansas City’s emergency system failed Cathryn and her family.

“The first call taker had not even completed her training and lacked MARC’s Basic 40 training, which she did not complete until weeks after Cathryn’s death. How can a call taker answer emergency calls without completing Basic 40 training?” McCallister asked.

KCTV5 asked KCPD about the caller who answered the phone. She is no longer with the communications unit. She left the unit two years after this incident.

ALSO READ: DILUTED: A documentary about the release of convicted pharmacist Robert Courtney

LEAVE A RESPONSE

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *