close
close

Yiamastaverna

Trusted News & Timely Insights

MSU football grades for the Spartans’ performance against Iowa
Colorado

MSU football grades for the Spartans’ performance against Iowa

play

Lansing State Journal columnist Graham Couch rates Michigan State’s performance in its 32-20 win over Iowa on a scale of 1-10.

INJURY: 8

Do you remember in school when you earned a B-minus grade but overperformed so much that the teacher couldn’t help but give you a grade? That’s it. MSU certainly left a lot of points on the field. But man, this was also the Spartans’ most complete performance of the season and it was a huge success. Quarterback Aidan Chiles delivered his best performance to date, completing 22 of 30 passes for 256 yards and a touchdown, with his only turnover, an interception, exceptionally not coming into the red zone and – because Iowa missed a long field goal – not MSU scored at all. Chiles made several memorable throws at the NFL level. His two top targets, freshman Nick Marsh and senior Montorie Foster, each reached 100 yards receiving and made critical plays. And MSU’s running game was truly a worthy complement to the passing game for the first time, totaling more than 200 yards on the ground and forcing Iowa to change its approach on defense.

DEFENSE: 8

What the MSU defense did in defending Iowa running back Kaleb Johnson — after struggling to contain Oregon’s Jordan James — showed much of the tenacity and focus that defense displayed in September. I thought they could bounce back. I didn’t expect that they would hold Johnson to 23 yards on 13 carries before he reached 98 yards on a 75-yard run. Johnson has run everyone better, even Ohio State. The MSU defense held Iowa to 283 total yards and, most importantly, did not allow the Hawkeyes a first down until the second quarter, giving the MSU offense a chance to come into the game and give the Spartans a chance to play from the front the entire game. Iowa’s limited passing game helped the Spartans’ cause, no question. And Iowa’s three second-half touchdowns could have made for a tricky finish. But that was still impressive against a team that trailed Washington by 40 points a week ago.

SPECIAL TEAMS: 8

One could argue that this score is actually low after MSU kicker Jonathan Kim set a school record with six made field goals on seven attempts – all but one from 42 yards or beyond. Without his leg and his calm nerves, MSU loses this game. But MSU wasn’t perfect on special teams either. Only two of Kim’s nine kickoffs were touchbacks, with most landing just in front of the goal line, allowing Iowa returner Kaden Wetjen to blow off steam. Wetjen was effective and appeared close to breaking a ball for a touchdown several times, including on returns of 36 and 39 yards. Kim said he got under the ball too much and, as Jonathan Smith admitted, MSU’s kick coverage was a little shaky. Still, there were six field goals and no punts, which is pretty darn good.

COACHING: 8

To date, no game has had a more positive impact on MSU’s first-year coaching staff than this one – in terms of growth, response and culture. The game calls and approach were also pretty good. Two weeks after the last time MSU’s defense was dismantled, Joe Rossi’s team was as disciplined and capable as we’ve ever seen against a similarly potent rushing attack (albeit a more one-dimensional offense). And offensively, MSU’s offensive line made hay like we’ve never seen against good teams, while coordinator Brian Lindgren kept the Spartans in rhythm and made everything click between the 20-yard lines.

MORE: Couch: The Michigan State football team shows competence and growth with a season-changing win over Iowa

CONCLUSION

After a bye week, MSU looked energized, focused and improved. And thus won a game that changed the direction of the season. This was a turning point in the first year under Jonathan Smith and Co. Lose it and there’s no telling how long the crash will last. Win it and you’re probably on your way to a bowl game. The Spartans won it – and looked good doing it – and now head into a rivalry game with a lot of confidence and good spirits.

MORE: 3 quick views of Michigan State’s 32-20 win over Iowa

Contact Graham Couch at [email protected]. Follow him on X @Graham_Couch.

LEAVE A RESPONSE

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *